SOS WI DOT Cancels ALL Pinz Titles!
-
- Posts: 1776
- Joined: Fri Apr 16, 2004 8:08 am
- Location: Blue Mounds, WI
Andy,
Well, we're certainly not relying only on that. There are other, more local, avenues which we are pursuing.
The impact of out of state comments is, of course, limited. Most elected officials are only concerned about their constituents' problems. To some degree, other people writing is seen as an annoyance.
We've already appealed to our elected officials on a "fairness" level. Like the unfairness of out-of-state owners driving on Wis. roads, while we taxpaying, voting, Wisconsin owners cannot. Like all the domestic HMVs, which are also nonconforming, still keep their licenses, while we who are exempted do not, etc. That didn't work.
We've already pointed out that we're exempted from FMVSS requirements under a variety of federal laws and regs. I've given them copies. They've basically said, "sue me".
Asking politely and rationally has not worked.
I guess, if I/we have to campaign nationally, so be it. Thus the suggestion that anyone might want to write. Not as a constituent, but as a U.S. citizen who is aware of what's going on and does not condone it. They are YOUR federal laws and regulations getting trampled on, too.
In a stampede, some poor sucker gets run down first. This time it's the Pinzgauers in Wisconsin. Next time???
Thanks for reading. What's the expression? Winners never quit, and quitters don't drive Pinzgauers. We'll keep posting.
Paul
Well, we're certainly not relying only on that. There are other, more local, avenues which we are pursuing.
The impact of out of state comments is, of course, limited. Most elected officials are only concerned about their constituents' problems. To some degree, other people writing is seen as an annoyance.
We've already appealed to our elected officials on a "fairness" level. Like the unfairness of out-of-state owners driving on Wis. roads, while we taxpaying, voting, Wisconsin owners cannot. Like all the domestic HMVs, which are also nonconforming, still keep their licenses, while we who are exempted do not, etc. That didn't work.
We've already pointed out that we're exempted from FMVSS requirements under a variety of federal laws and regs. I've given them copies. They've basically said, "sue me".
Asking politely and rationally has not worked.
I guess, if I/we have to campaign nationally, so be it. Thus the suggestion that anyone might want to write. Not as a constituent, but as a U.S. citizen who is aware of what's going on and does not condone it. They are YOUR federal laws and regulations getting trampled on, too.
In a stampede, some poor sucker gets run down first. This time it's the Pinzgauers in Wisconsin. Next time???
Thanks for reading. What's the expression? Winners never quit, and quitters don't drive Pinzgauers. We'll keep posting.
Paul
Perhaps you could make a small business (LLC) in another state, include a family member in that state, make sure you have permanent management control of the LLC, give family member 1% of stock in company. Transfer title of vehicle to company and register in the other state. That Wis. statute will no longer apply to you. Unfortunately it may cost more to register under a business.undysworld wrote:While I appreciate your suggestion, s. 341.40(1)(b) requires that any vehicle owned by a Wisconsin citizen falls under Wisconsin registration requirements if it is operated in Wisconsin.
s. 341.03(2)(a) sets the fine at less than $200.
russ
If you didn't get stuck, you didn't try hard enough.
'74 710K
1984 in 2009
'74 710K
1984 in 2009
- GenevaPinz
- Posts: 520
- Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2008 12:00 pm
- Location: near Perth, Scotland
Only the two cents from a Swiss guy that doen't know a thing about US Federal or State laws, but would it be possible to set up something like this for several (or all) Wisconsin owners in order to split the cost? (I mean, any kind of legal entity based in a neigbouring state that could legally own the vehicles while still giving the owners some comfort that they actually keep their vehicles).russ wrote:Perhaps you could make a small business (LLC) in another state, include a family member in that state, make sure you have permanent management control of the LLC, give family member 1% of stock in company. Transfer title of vehicle to company and register in the other state. That Wis. statute will no longer apply to you. Unfortunately it may cost more to register under a business.undysworld wrote:While I appreciate your suggestion, s. 341.40(1)(b) requires that any vehicle owned by a Wisconsin citizen falls under Wisconsin registration requirements if it is operated in Wisconsin.
s. 341.03(2)(a) sets the fine at less than $200.
russ
Probably not the easiest to put together, and in no way a solution to change the law or prevent the Wisconsin situation from spreading to other states, but... as I said just my 2 cents (or probably less).
Jan
Jan
'72 Pinzgauer 710M
'72 Pinzgauer 710M
-
- Posts: 1776
- Joined: Fri Apr 16, 2004 8:08 am
- Location: Blue Mounds, WI
Russ,
Thank you for an interesting suggestion. I'll have to explore that. The corp. being an "entity", I would have to assume that the Wis. law wouldn't apply. Interesting. I like it.
I understand Fla. is Pinzgauer-licensing-friendly. Wanna adopt a son? The benefits would be a second Pinz in the family and the pitter-patter of big feet in the house.
I'd deed the truck to the company, which would form my basis, investment wise. Plus, then I could maybe write off "business losses". Like, oh, licensing fees? Insurance?? Gas???
Maybe I can get a "job" working for the state of Florida, advertising tourism or something. My work would involve the midwest region, say, Wisconsin.
All right, I'm too tired and rambling.
Thanks for your ideas.
Paul
Thank you for an interesting suggestion. I'll have to explore that. The corp. being an "entity", I would have to assume that the Wis. law wouldn't apply. Interesting. I like it.
I understand Fla. is Pinzgauer-licensing-friendly. Wanna adopt a son? The benefits would be a second Pinz in the family and the pitter-patter of big feet in the house.
I'd deed the truck to the company, which would form my basis, investment wise. Plus, then I could maybe write off "business losses". Like, oh, licensing fees? Insurance?? Gas???
Maybe I can get a "job" working for the state of Florida, advertising tourism or something. My work would involve the midwest region, say, Wisconsin.
All right, I'm too tired and rambling.
Thanks for your ideas.
Paul
-
- Posts: 1062
- Joined: Mon Nov 19, 2007 2:43 pm
- Location: Houston, Texas USA
I can help you in Texas too and I already operate as an LLC here. PM me if you want to discuss this option.
Looking for next new (for me) toy
1974 712M - sold
1973 710M - sold
https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id ... 3094951494
1974 712M - sold
1973 710M - sold
https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id ... 3094951494
-
- Posts: 1776
- Joined: Fri Apr 16, 2004 8:08 am
- Location: Blue Mounds, WI
Hi all,
We are in the local Madison, WI newspaper, Isthmus, yesterday. It's available on-line here: http://thedailypage.com
Patrick Robb (CWR) is cited. It's short, but sympathetic.
The author of the article, Bill Lueders, also went on WTDY 1670am yesterday at 1pm to discuss the week's issue. His first topic was our article and he spent about 5 minutes giving the specifics.
This afternoon, WKOW Ch. 27 ABC affiliate, was here for an interview. Dave Arndt brought out his truck and we got a great opportunity to give our argument. It will air at 10pm tonight.
NEVER give up.
Stay tuned....
Paul
We are in the local Madison, WI newspaper, Isthmus, yesterday. It's available on-line here: http://thedailypage.com
Patrick Robb (CWR) is cited. It's short, but sympathetic.
The author of the article, Bill Lueders, also went on WTDY 1670am yesterday at 1pm to discuss the week's issue. His first topic was our article and he spent about 5 minutes giving the specifics.
This afternoon, WKOW Ch. 27 ABC affiliate, was here for an interview. Dave Arndt brought out his truck and we got a great opportunity to give our argument. It will air at 10pm tonight.
NEVER give up.
Stay tuned....
Paul
-
- Posts: 1776
- Joined: Fri Apr 16, 2004 8:08 am
- Location: Blue Mounds, WI
Hi Russ,
Yes, that's what we've been told, unofficially.
I have no intention of quitting until the federal laws and regulations are recognized by Wisconsin DOT, with regard to our trucks.
WisDOT claims they cannot do anything until, maybe, 2009, as this is a longstanding practice which is not clearly erroneous. I say bullshit.
This "practice", from evidence I've found, began September 25, 2007. That makes it less than 8 months old. The WisDOT atty. considers their interpretation of the pertinent statute to be "clearly erroneous". But he claims that a DIFFERENT interpretation of that statute was used in cancelling our titles/plates. (How many different interpretations of a statute can there be?)
I've currently got two requests in to them for clarification and substantiation of their recent claims under Wisconsin's Public Records Law. We'll see what they can produce. It's already been three weeks. I'll start rattling them on the delay soon.
I believe I've nearly got enough evidence to start up court proceedings. It may well come to that. We've asked politely, with no results. I won't waste my time again.
I've recently documented additional inconsistencies in their position which belie their most recent assertions. If it makes them look incompetent, it's really not my concern.
I don't expect this to resolve itself too soon. But I certainly intend to make it interesting. I'd prefer not to get too much more specific at this time. I'll post info as I can.
Never stop.
Paul
Yes, that's what we've been told, unofficially.
I have no intention of quitting until the federal laws and regulations are recognized by Wisconsin DOT, with regard to our trucks.
WisDOT claims they cannot do anything until, maybe, 2009, as this is a longstanding practice which is not clearly erroneous. I say bullshit.
This "practice", from evidence I've found, began September 25, 2007. That makes it less than 8 months old. The WisDOT atty. considers their interpretation of the pertinent statute to be "clearly erroneous". But he claims that a DIFFERENT interpretation of that statute was used in cancelling our titles/plates. (How many different interpretations of a statute can there be?)
I've currently got two requests in to them for clarification and substantiation of their recent claims under Wisconsin's Public Records Law. We'll see what they can produce. It's already been three weeks. I'll start rattling them on the delay soon.
I believe I've nearly got enough evidence to start up court proceedings. It may well come to that. We've asked politely, with no results. I won't waste my time again.
I've recently documented additional inconsistencies in their position which belie their most recent assertions. If it makes them look incompetent, it's really not my concern.
I don't expect this to resolve itself too soon. But I certainly intend to make it interesting. I'd prefer not to get too much more specific at this time. I'll post info as I can.
Never stop.
Paul
-
- Posts: 1776
- Joined: Fri Apr 16, 2004 8:08 am
- Location: Blue Mounds, WI
I am scheduled for a Prehearing Telephone Conference, next Thursday, with an Administrative Law Judge from the Department of Administration, Division of Hearings and Appeals.I intend to find out what he has to say about things around here. Presuming it goes well, we'll begin the legal process.
Yesterday, I dropped off a large packet of info to my state senator, per their request. I'm making the argument that WisDOT need not wait for legislative action before reinstating our titles/license plates.
It's a good thing I've got nothing else to do in life..... Not.
Anyway, stay tuned.
Paul
Yesterday, I dropped off a large packet of info to my state senator, per their request. I'm making the argument that WisDOT need not wait for legislative action before reinstating our titles/license plates.
It's a good thing I've got nothing else to do in life..... Not.
Anyway, stay tuned.
Paul
-
- Posts: 1776
- Joined: Fri Apr 16, 2004 8:08 am
- Location: Blue Mounds, WI
Thanks Andy,
I've yet to talk to anybody who thinks WisDOT is correct and we're wrong. But it's always nice to be reminded of other folks' support. Thank you.
One last update for the night:
Patrick Robb, of Cold War Remarketing, has come through! WisDOT claims to be "unable to return" my original registration paperwork. Patrick has supplied me with all of the original importation details. The U.S.DOT has offered to write me a letter attesting to the legal importation of my truck, once I provide them with these details.
From Paul and all the other Wisconsin Pinzgauer Owners:
THANK YOU PATRICK!!
I've yet to talk to anybody who thinks WisDOT is correct and we're wrong. But it's always nice to be reminded of other folks' support. Thank you.
One last update for the night:
Patrick Robb, of Cold War Remarketing, has come through! WisDOT claims to be "unable to return" my original registration paperwork. Patrick has supplied me with all of the original importation details. The U.S.DOT has offered to write me a letter attesting to the legal importation of my truck, once I provide them with these details.
From Paul and all the other Wisconsin Pinzgauer Owners:
THANK YOU PATRICK!!
-
- Posts: 1776
- Joined: Fri Apr 16, 2004 8:08 am
- Location: Blue Mounds, WI
The legal process has begun. I participated in a Telephone Prehearing Conference call this morning. I anticipate a hearing mid-July before a Judge.
It's probably not prudent to comment publicly on details at this point.
I did hear from Dennis @ Linden and also from Per E. that they will be getting together for photos as part of a comparison study between ex-mil and civvy Pinz's.
To Everyone: You know who you are, and I cannot thank you enough for the help.
It's proving to be a very busy summer, indeed.
Later,
Paul
It's probably not prudent to comment publicly on details at this point.
I did hear from Dennis @ Linden and also from Per E. that they will be getting together for photos as part of a comparison study between ex-mil and civvy Pinz's.
To Everyone: You know who you are, and I cannot thank you enough for the help.
It's proving to be a very busy summer, indeed.
Later,
Paul